Expect modestly positive growth for West Michigan economy
The holidays are over, and we are now into the back-to-work mode of 2017. According to the latest survey conducted during the last two weeks of January, New Orders, our index of business improvement, has returned to a normal pace of plus-8, up nicely from December’s minus-5.
Most of our other key indexes also were modestly positive. The Production index edged up to plus-8 from plus-3. Activity in the purchasing offices, the index of Purchases, crept up to plus-6 from plus-3. The January index representing Finished Goods Inventories came back to breakeven at 0, but the fear of more price increases drove the Raw Materials Inventories index to rise to plus-11 from plus-4. Much as we suspected, the January numbers reflect the mood of a new year. But many of our industrial groups are showing signs of topping out, so growth for the first quarter in West Michigan probably will be just modestly positive.
Looking at individual industrial groups, the auto parts suppliers continue to raise concern over the recent softening in auto sales but remain positive about the 2017 outlook. For the office furniture industry, most signs point toward sales topping out. Typical of past years, the January trend for the capital equipment manufacturers was modestly positive. The performance for the industrial distributors also was modestly better than December. Last but not least, our survey has a few firms tied in to the residential housing industry, and the strong housing market has fueled some significant growth for the Tier I and II suppliers that survived the housing crisis.
It was gratifying to see the business sentiment numbers for January continue to improve. The Short Term Business Outlook, which asks local firms about the perception of the next three to six months, rose to plus-28 from plus-20. Looking out three to five years, the Long Term Business Outlook edged marginally higher to plus-47 from plus-45.
At the national level, the Feb. 1 report from the Institute for Supply Management, our parent organization, continued to head in a decidedly positive direction. New Orders, ISM’s index of business improvement, came in at plus-16, up from plus-12 in December and plus-4 in November. The Production index rose modestly to plus-14 from plus-11. ISM’s Employment index turned in one of the best reports in two years and rose to plus-8 from plus-3. ISM’s overall index for January jumped to 56.0 from 54.5. According to the survey author, the index of 56.0 is comparable with a 4 percent increase in the national GDP.
Another “strong start” report comes from the U.S. survey conducted by Markit, the British economics consulting firm. Growth in New Orders accelerated to a 28-month high. The Markit PMI for the U.S. came in at 55.0, up from 54.2 in December.
Comments from Chris Williamson, the chief business economist at Markit, continue to be positive: “Despite exports being subdued by the strong dollar, order books are growing at the fastest pace in over two years on the back of improved domestic demand. With optimism about the year ahead at the highest since last March, the outlook has also brightened. Production is consequently growing at the strongest rate for almost two years, and inventories are rising at a rate not seen for nearly a decade, as firms respond to higher demand, suggesting the goods-producing sector will make a decent contribution to first quarter GDP.”
The Feb. 1 report from the JPMorgan Global Manufacturing survey of 31 nations reported more optimism for improvement in the world economy. JPM’s index of New Orders once again edged higher to 53.9 from 53.7. The Production index backtracked slightly to 53.7 from 53.9. The JPMorgan Global Composite Purchasing Managers Index remained unchanged at 52.7, a repeat of a 34-month high. The rate of improvement in business conditions hit a 70-month record in Austria, a three-month high in Germany and remained elevated in the Netherlands despite easing to a three-month low. Strong growth also was signaled in Spain (20-month high) and Ireland. The French PMI rose to a 68-month high. In contrast, the downturn in Greece accelerated. The U.K posted a 30-month high, and even Russia turned in the best performance in two years.
David Hensley, the survey author, further noted: “Business conditions in the global manufacturing sector improved at a solid pace in January, with output, new orders and employment all expanding at similar rates to December. With backlogs of work rising further and business confidence increasing, the sector looks firmly set to build on this solid start to the New Year during the coming months.”
How long will the “Trump rally” last? As we have pointed out for the past two reports, at least some respondents feel the post-election mood has resulted in a more optimistic outlook for 2017. A recent index of confidence among small businesses posted the greatest increase in the 30-year history of the survey. The biggest incentive for small businesses is the possibility of corporate tax rates being lowered by historical proportions. Over the past 70 years, the tax code has grown extremely complicated, and most small businesses simply do not have large enough staffs to examine all of the loopholes to reduce their tax rates below the widely known statutory rate of 35 percent. Although the proposed percent rate is probably not realistic, a rate of 20 percent is more likely. The revenue should remain relatively stable, because the tax loopholes and many pages of the tax code will be cut. However, it is the larger corporations that are successfully utilizing these loopholes, and their lobbyists will not allow them to disappear without a fight.
What about the proposal to repatriate the $2.6 trillion multinational corporations are holding overseas? First, all firms will not want to bring all of their offshore money back, because they still plan to reinvest plenty of money around the world. For instance, about 64 percent of IBM’s revenue comes from operations outside of the United States. For Dow Chemical, 67 percent of the firm’s business is offshore, and Intel, the world’s leader in computer processing chips, receives a whopping 85 percent of its revenue from the rest of the world. Overall, both history and logic indicate the lion's share of the repatriated money will be used to buy back shares rather than to grow top-line revenues and hire hundreds of new people. But short term, a one-time repatriation rate of, say, 10 percent could help offset the revenue impact of a tax cut.
According to the current data, there is little doubt industrial inflation is on the rise. Our local index of Prices rose to plus-30, up from plus-21 in December. JPM’s December index of Prices jumped to 61.9 from 61.0, a six-year high. Many of the increases can be attributed to the recent increase in oil prices. In addition, steel, aluminum and copper are rising in price, and some buyers are worried there is no end in sight. One fortunate fact: Unlike inflation 50 years ago, industrial inflation no longer automatically flows over into the consumer market.
Much as we expected, the sales statistics for automobiles have continued to moderate, and the year-over-year sales for January eased by 1.9 percent. For good reason, our automotive parts suppliers in West Michigan are beginning to be cautious. Looking at January sales, Ford posted a minor decline of 0.7 percent, followed by a 3.8 percent decline at General Motors and a 10.9 percent drop at Fiat-Chrysler. For the other major brands, Honda rose 5.9 percent, Nissan added 6.2 percent, and Subaru gained 6.8 percent. The big loser was the 11.3 percent drop at Toyota. For a long time, we have expected that auto sales eventually would top out and begin to edge lower. So far, the decline seems to be very orderly, which should hopefully allow the auto parts suppliers to readjust accordingly. But the rapid expansion among many of our local auto parts suppliers probably is over.
In summary, the current economic momentum is positive, which means there is no recession on the horizon. Based on the current positive momentum, the overall economy should remain solid for the next few months.
With all of this good news, what could possibly go wrong? Plenty. First, one major terrorist act that involved any part of the infrastructure (airlines, power grid, magnetic pulse) would mean that we would probably find ourselves in a recession overnight. Second, a fiscal default by any major country, such as China or even Greece, could weaken the world economy and possibly spill over into our domestic economy. Third, if the impending trade negotiations go poorly with Mexico or China and tariffs are imposed, a trade war could easily throw us into a recession. Last but not least, a new extended military action, such as bombing the nuclear sites in Iran, could destabilize world order. President Donald Trump indicated he may take some kind of military action just to show there is a “new sheriff in town.” If this action were to escalate, it could easily put a damper on the economy and possibly spawn a recession. Trump is going to have to be very careful not to upset his own applecart.
Brian Long is director of supply management research at Seidman College of Business, Grand Valley State University.