- people on the move
A green kind of clean
Cleaning companies pivot to traditional, environmentally friendly methods to combat harmful effects.
It appears antibacterial products aren’t as beneficial as advertised.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration recently started prohibiting manufacturers from marketing over-the-counter consumer antiseptic wash products with one or more of 19 ingredients.
The ban, which took effect in September, includes two of the most common ingredients, triclosan and triclocarban, which are found in antibacterial hand soap and body wash.
“Consumers may think antibacterial washes are more effective at preventing the spread of germs, but we have no scientific evidence that they are any better than plain soap and water,” said Janet Woodcock, M.D., director of the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER). “In fact, some data suggest that antibacterial ingredients may do more harm than good over the long term.”
The ban comes after antibacterial hand and body wash manufacturers failed to provide sufficient evidence that proves the health benefits of the ingredients, according to the FDA. The administration recommends using soap and water.
Reverting to traditional methods has spread across the industry, including cleaning companies. Although there are no specific state and national regulations that dictate the type of cleaning products companies must use, many cleaning companies have become environmentally friendly but also have become more aware of the health safety.
Renae Hesselink, vice president of sustainability at Nichols in Norton Shores, said some hazardous cleaning products include bleach, glass cleaners that have ammonia, and toilet bowl cleaners that contain chlorine.
“If you are using harsh chemicals and you are dumping them down the drain, no doubt some of that gets into the water supply,” Hesselink said. “If you are in a municipality, an urban area, it goes through a wastewater treatment cycle, but still, that takes energy to clean that water. So, anything you are dumping down the drain is not good.”
Eric Mosley, owner of Grand Rapids-based Furst Cleaning Services, said over time, cleaning companies have become aware of the harmful effect of cleaning products since he opened his business in 2000.
Mosley said he didn’t change the type of cleaning products he was using until around 2008 when he was bidding on contracts for office buildings.
“Some guy was there boasting, ‘Yeah, all my products are green,’ and I am like, ‘What is he talking about, what’s green?’” Mosley said.
After doing some research, Mosley said he realized he needed to switch his products and use the products that aren't harsh on the environment. He also works with chemical waste-collecting companies, such as Plummer’s Waste Group.
“I think green cleaning and eco-cleaning, and not leaving your carbon footprint on the Earth really changed a lot of chemicals,” Mosley said.
Matt Koster of Enviro-Clean Services, a commercial cleaning company, said the majority of the chemicals the business uses are green certified, including glass cleaners and floor cleaners.
Hesselink, who also is a founding member of the U.S. Green Building Council West Michigan chapter, said with more awareness, more illness can be prevented.
“We all probably know someone who has asthma or some kind of breathing problem and using green products is safer for someone who has an illness like that,” she said. “It is not going to cure someone who has asthma, but it can help to prevent an attack from a green chemical versus a nongreen chemical.”
Being exposed to certain chemicals can pose a health risk and become an environmental hazard. That is why Mosley said he promotes a cleaner environment with the type of products his company uses. The FDA said it is continuing to take aggressive actions in reviewing all the active ingredients in “over-the-counter antiseptic rubs and wash products.”